OptinMonster vs Privy: which one should you choose?
Quick answer: Choose OptinMonster if you want popups on any website, a library of 700+ templates and detailed targeting, and you already use an email tool; Basic is $9/month in the first year, billed yearly. Choose Privy if you run a store on Shopify, BigCommerce or Wix and want pop-ups, email and SMS in one tool with monthly pricing, from $24/month for pop-ups only.
OptinMonster vs Privy at a glance
| OptinMonster | Privy | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $9/month (Basic, first year, billed yearly); renews at $210/year | Pop-ups only from $24/month; email + SMS from $30/month |
| Free plan / trial | Free test drive with 500 impressions | 15-day free trial, no card; no permanent free plan |
| Entry plan limits | 1 site, 2,500 impressions/month | Up to 10,000 page views on Pop-ups & Displays |
| Billing | Yearly, paid upfront | Monthly |
| Exit intent | From the Pro plan | Listed as a pop-up feature |
| A/B testing | From the Plus plan | Included in the Pop-ups & Displays plan |
| Email and SMS | Connects to email marketing tools; Zapier on Pro | Built-in email and SMS; SMS in the US and Canada only |
| Best for | Site owners growing an email list | Small and mid-size online stores |
From each official site, checked November 15, 2026. Prices change, so confirm before you buy.
Key differences
- OptinMonster is a popup and opt-in form builder that passes leads to the email tool you already use, while Privy includes its own email editor, automated flows and SMS campaigns.
- Privy is built for stores and syncs directly with Shopify, BigCommerce and Wix; OptinMonster is aimed at bloggers, stores and businesses in general.
- OptinMonster's prices are first-year offers paid upfront for a year that renew at a higher yearly price, for example Basic at $108 for the first year and $210 a year after; Privy lists monthly prices.
- OptinMonster limits plans by sites and monthly impressions, while Privy's pop-ups plan is limited by page views and its email price rises with the number of mailable contacts.
- OptinMonster keeps Exit Intent for the Pro plan and A/B testing for Plus and above, and it has a 14-day money-back guarantee; Privy has a 15-day free trial with no card needed.
In one line each
OptinMonster
Popup and opt-in form builder that turns website visitors into email subscribers and sales. Starting price: $9/month (Basic, first year billed yearly). Free plan / trial: Free test drive with 500 impressions. Best for: Site owners growing an email list.
Read the full OptinMonster summary →Privy
Email, SMS and pop-up tools built for online stores on Shopify, BigCommerce and Wix. Starting price: $30/month (email, up to 1,500 contacts). Free plan / trial: 15-day free trial, no card needed. Best for: Small and mid-size online stores.
Read the full Privy summary →Frequently asked questions
Is OptinMonster cheaper than Privy?
On the listed entry prices, yes: OptinMonster Basic is $9 per month in the first year, billed yearly, and renews at $210 per year, while Privy's pop-ups plan starts at $24 per month. The limits differ, though: OptinMonster Basic covers 2,500 impressions a month on 1 site, and Privy's pop-ups plan covers up to 10,000 page views.
Does OptinMonster or Privy have a free plan?
Neither lists a permanent free plan. OptinMonster offers a free test drive limited to 500 impressions and a 14-day money-back guarantee. Privy offers a 15-day free trial with no card needed.
Which is better for a Shopify store, OptinMonster or Privy?
Privy is the closer fit, because it syncs directly with Shopify and adds abandoned cart flows, email and SMS to its pop-ups. OptinMonster suits a store that already has an email tool and mainly wants more templates and targeting rules for popups.
Can OptinMonster or Privy send emails?
Privy can: it has a drag-and-drop email editor, automated flows such as welcome and abandoned cart, and SMS in the US and Canada. OptinMonster collects subscribers and connects to email marketing tools, so you send the emails from the tool you already use.
See all marketing & seo tools compared →
We summarise each product from its official website, pricing page and documentation. We don't run hands-on tests or give star ratings. Some links on this site may be affiliate links. See our affiliate disclosure.