Horse Saddle Shop review: what it is, pricing and who it's for
Family-run Indiana store selling new and used Western and English saddles, tack, boots and riding gear.
In short: Family-run Indiana store selling new and used Western and English saddles, tack, boots and riding gear. Best for: Riders buying a saddle online with trade-in or payment options.
What is Horse Saddle Shop?
Horse Saddle Shop is an online store run by a family business in Bremen, Indiana. It sells Western and English saddles, used saddles, kids' saddles, saddle pads, tack, boots, clothing and gifts. Brands on the site include Circle Y, Billy Cook, Cashel, Dakota, High Horse and Ariat, and the store says it keeps more than 900 saddles in stock.
You order online or by phone. Saddles ship free by ground within the continental US, and orders placed before midday Eastern time usually ship the same day. The store also ships to Canada and other countries, runs a trade-in program for used saddles and offers financing options at checkout.
Key features
- Large saddle range: Western, English, used and kids' saddles in one place.
- Well-known saddle brands such as Circle Y, Billy Cook, Cashel and High Horse.
- Free ground shipping on saddles within the continental US.
- Free economy or standard shipping on other orders over $85 (continental US).
- Trade-in program for your old saddle.
- Financing options for larger purchases.
- International shipping by airmail parcel post, with rates shown at checkout.
- A low-cost saddle fit tool to help check fit before buying.
Plans and pricing
| Plan | Price / limit | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Saddle fit tool | $9.95 | Simple tool to check saddle fit at home |
| Trail saddles | From about $1,499 | E.g. High Horse/Circle Y trail models; higher-end Circle Y and Cashel trail saddles cost $2,699-$2,899 |
| All-around saddles | About $3,350 | E.g. Billy Cook ladies' all-around saddle |
| Shipping | Free on saddles (continental US) | Other orders free over $85 (economy/standard); Alaska, Hawaii, Canada and overseas charged at checkout |
| Returns | 30 days from delivery | RMA number needed; unused with tags; 5% restocking fee on refunds; buyer pays return shipping |
Prices are in US dollars and change often; the figures below are examples from the store's best-seller list on 21 Nov 2026.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Very large stock of saddles from known brands.
- Free shipping on saddles inside the continental US.
- Trade-in program and financing make big purchases easier.
- Long-running family business with phone support.
Cons
- Refunds carry a 5% restocking fee and you pay return shipping.
- Returns must be unused with no scuffs or horsehair, which is hard if you test a saddle on a horse.
- Custom or special-order saddles carry an extra return fee, and some can't be returned.
- Buyers outside the US pay their own duties and taxes.
Who it's for
A good fit for US riders who want a wide choice of Western saddles and like free saddle shipping. If you want to ride in a saddle for a while before committing, check the strict return conditions first or buy from a local tack shop.
Frequently asked questions
What is Horse Saddle Shop?
Horse Saddle Shop is an online store run by a family business in Bremen, Indiana. It sells Western and English saddles, used saddles, kids' saddles, saddle pads, tack, boots, clothing and gifts. Brands on the site include Circle Y, Billy Cook, Cashel, Dakota, High Horse and Ariat, and the store says it keeps more than 900 saddles in stock.
How much does Horse Saddle Shop cost?
Prices are in US dollars and change often; the figures below are examples from the store's best-seller list on 21 Nov 2026.
Who is Horse Saddle Shop best for?
A good fit for US riders who want a wide choice of Western saddles and like free saddle shipping. If you want to ride in a saddle for a while before committing, check the strict return conditions first or buy from a local tack shop.
What are the downsides of Horse Saddle Shop?
Main drawbacks: Refunds carry a 5% restocking fee and you pay return shipping. Returns must be unused with no scuffs or horsehair, which is hard if you test a saddle on a horse. Custom or special-order saddles carry an extra return fee, and some can't be returned. Buyers outside the US pay their own duties and taxes.
What are some alternatives to Horse Saddle Shop?
Other pet supplies options we cover include PetSafe Gentle Leader, Impact Dog Crates, Gunner Kennels, Furbo and Wisdom Panel.
Head-to-head comparisons
Other pet supplies options
PetSafe Gentle Leader
Pet SuppliesNo-pull dog headcollar from PetSafe, a brand that also sells fences, feeders, fountains and doors.
Impact Dog Crates
Pet SuppliesHeavy-duty, US-made aluminum dog crates for travel, anxious dogs and working dogs, with a lifetime warranty.
Gunner Kennels
Pet SuppliesDouble-walled dog kennels for car travel, with crash-test certification on several sizes.
Furbo
Pet SuppliesTreat-tossing pet cameras with 360° view, two-way audio and barking alerts, plus an optional smart alert plan.
Wisdom Panel
Pet SuppliesAt-home DNA tests for dogs and cats that report breed mix, genetic health risks and traits.
Halo Collar
Pet SuppliesGPS dog collar that sets virtual fences in an app, with tracking and training feedback.
Smalls
Pet SuppliesFresh, gently cooked cat food delivered to your door, plus freeze-dried food and treats.
Bulk Reef Supply
Pet SuppliesSaltwater and reef aquarium supply store with its own BRS product line and 365-day returns.
Ruffwear
Pet SuppliesOutdoor dog gear such as harnesses, leashes, boots, jackets and life jackets, backed by a defect guarantee.
State Line Tack
Pet SuppliesFamily-owned online equestrian store for tack, horse blankets, supplements, apparel and stable supplies.
BringFido
Pet SuppliesPet-friendly travel site and app for booking dog-friendly hotels and finding places to go with your pet.
Josh's Frogs
Pet SuppliesOnline shop for captive-bred frogs, reptiles, feeder insects and terrarium supplies, with a live arrival guarantee.
Petco
Pet SuppliesUS pet retailer selling food and supplies online and in stores, with grooming and vet services.
Lyka
Pet SuppliesAustralian fresh, gently cooked dog food subscription with portions set to your dog's needs.
Pure Pet Food
Pet SuppliesUK dog food subscription: dried natural meals you rehydrate with water, delivered free to your door.
DOGTV
Pet SuppliesA streaming channel made for dogs, with calming and stimulating video and sound for when they're home alone.
Omlet
Pet SuppliesDesigner chicken coops, catios, rabbit hutches and pet gear known for the plastic Eglu coop range.
Compare all pet supplies side by side →
This summary is based on Horse Saddle Shop's official website, pricing page and public documentation as of November 21, 2026. Prices and features change, so confirm the details on the official site. Some links on this site may be affiliate links. See our affiliate disclosure.