Home / Best picks / Horse Saddle Shop vs State Line Tack
Pet Supplies

Horse Saddle Shop vs State Line Tack: which one should you choose?

Last updated November 21, 2026

Quick answer: Choose Horse Saddle Shop if you are buying a saddle: it stocks new and used Western and English saddles, ships saddles free by ground in the continental US, and offers trade-ins and financing. Choose State Line Tack if you want one US store for tack, horse blankets, supplements, rider apparel and stable supplies, with 2% back on purchases.

Horse Saddle Shop vs State Line Tack at a glance

Horse Saddle ShopState Line Tack
TypeOnline saddle and tack store, family owned since 1986 (Bremen, Indiana)Family-owned online equestrian supply store
PricesSmall items from about $10; saddles roughly $1,500 to $3,350+See official site
Main focusWestern, English, used and kids' saddles, plus tack, boots and riding gearSaddles, tack, blankets, supplements, apparel and stable supplies
Free shippingSaddles free by ground (continental US); other orders free over $85Only on items marked on product pages (lower 48 states)
Ships toUS, plus international by airmail parcel postUS only; Alaska and Hawaii pay a $29.95 fee plus shipping
Returns30 days, unused with tags; 5% restocking fee on refunds; buyer pays return shipping30 days, new and unused; 10% restocking fee on saddles; return shipping not refunded
ExtrasSaddle trade-in, financing, $9.95 saddle fit toolRewards with 2% back on product purchases
Best forRiders buying a saddle onlineUS horse owners who want many supplies from one shop

From each official site, checked November 21, 2026. Prices change, so confirm before you buy.

Key differences

  • Horse Saddle Shop centers on saddles, with Western, English, used and kids' saddles from brands such as Circle Y, Billy Cook, Cashel and High Horse, while State Line Tack covers a wider mix of horse and rider supplies.
  • Horse Saddle Shop ships saddles free by ground in the continental US and other orders free over $85, while State Line Tack has no general free-shipping threshold and ships free only on marked items.
  • Saddle returns cost less at Horse Saddle Shop, with a 5% restocking fee on refunds, against a 10% restocking fee on saddles at State Line Tack; at both stores the buyer pays return shipping.
  • Horse Saddle Shop ships outside the US by airmail parcel post, while State Line Tack ships only within the US.
  • Horse Saddle Shop offers a saddle trade-in program and financing, while State Line Tack gives 2% back on product purchases through its rewards program.

In one line each

Horse Saddle Shop

Family-run Indiana store selling new and used Western and English saddles, tack, boots and riding gear. Best for: Riders buying a saddle online with trade-in or payment options.

Read the full Horse Saddle Shop summary →

State Line Tack

Family-owned online equestrian store for tack, horse blankets, supplements, apparel and stable supplies. Starting price: See official site. Best for: Horse owners and riders in the US.

Read the full State Line Tack summary →

Frequently asked questions

Which is better for buying a saddle, Horse Saddle Shop or State Line Tack?

Horse Saddle Shop is built around saddles, with new and used Western and English models, free ground shipping on saddles in the continental US and a trade-in program. State Line Tack also sells saddles, but its strength is a broad range of tack, blankets, supplements and stable supplies.

Does Horse Saddle Shop or State Line Tack have free shipping?

Horse Saddle Shop ships saddles free by ground in the continental US and other orders free over $85 by economy or standard shipping. State Line Tack offers free economy shipping only on items marked on product pages in the lower 48 states; other shipping is calculated at checkout.

Can I return a saddle to Horse Saddle Shop or State Line Tack?

Yes, within 30 days at both, if the saddle is unused. Horse Saddle Shop takes a 5% restocking fee on refunds and needs an RMA number, and State Line Tack charges a 10% restocking fee on saddles. At both stores you pay return shipping.

Do Horse Saddle Shop and State Line Tack ship outside the US?

Horse Saddle Shop ships internationally by airmail parcel post, and buyers pay their own duties and taxes. State Line Tack does not ship outside the US.

See all pet supplies compared →

We summarise each product from its official website, pricing page and documentation. We don't run hands-on tests or give star ratings. Some links on this site may be affiliate links. See our affiliate disclosure.