Star City Games review: what it is, pricing and who it's for
Large US store for Magic: The Gathering singles and sealed product, plus other trading card games and events.
In short: Large US store for Magic: The Gathering singles and sealed product, plus other trading card games and events. Best for: Magic players and collectors.
What is Star City Games?
Star City Games is a US online store best known for Magic: The Gathering. It sells single cards in several conditions and sealed products like boosters and boxes, and also carries Pokémon, Lorcana, Flesh and Blood, Riftbound and other card games.
You can also sell cards to the store, either by building an itemized sell list or by mailing cards through its Ship + Sell program. The company runs SCG CON and other tournament events across the US.
Key features
- Large catalog of Magic: The Gathering singles in multiple conditions.
- Sealed product for Magic, Pokémon and other games.
- Sell List to lock in buy prices before mailing cards.
- Ship + Sell option to mail cards without itemizing them.
- Payouts as store credit, PayPal or check.
- SCG CON tournaments and other events in US cities.
- Combining orders can refund shipping savings as store credit.
Plans and pricing
| Plan | Price / limit | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Magic singles | See official site | Priced per card and condition |
| Sealed product | See official site | Boosters, boxes and bundles |
| Selling cards | Store credit, PayPal or check | Store credit pays a higher rate than cash |
| Shipping | Varies | Based on items, weight, value, address and method |
Card prices change daily with the market, so see the official site; shipping cost depends on item count, weight, value, address and method, and free-shipping offers have been time-limited promotions.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Very large Magic singles selection.
- Can sell your cards back for credit or cash.
- Carries many newer card games too.
- Runs in-person events and tournaments.
Cons
- No standing free-shipping threshold; free shipping has been promo-only.
- Card prices move with the market and can be higher than marketplaces.
- Cash payouts for sold cards are lower than store credit.
- Itemized selling search covers Magic cards only.
Who it's for
A strong choice for Magic: The Gathering players who want a big singles catalog and a way to sell cards. Casual buyers chasing the lowest price may compare marketplaces first.
Frequently asked questions
What is Star City Games?
Star City Games is a US online store best known for Magic: The Gathering. It sells single cards in several conditions and sealed products like boosters and boxes, and also carries Pokémon, Lorcana, Flesh and Blood, Riftbound and other card games.
How much does Star City Games cost?
Card prices change daily with the market, so see the official site; shipping cost depends on item count, weight, value, address and method, and free-shipping offers have been time-limited promotions.
Who is Star City Games best for?
A strong choice for Magic: The Gathering players who want a big singles catalog and a way to sell cards. Casual buyers chasing the lowest price may compare marketplaces first.
What are the downsides of Star City Games?
Main drawbacks: No standing free-shipping threshold; free shipping has been promo-only. Card prices move with the market and can be higher than marketplaces. Cash payouts for sold cards are lower than store credit. Itemized selling search covers Magic cards only.
What are some alternatives to Star City Games?
Other hobbies & crafts options we cover include Field Notes, Connecting Threads, Warlord Games, Piecework Puzzles and Redcat Racing.
Other hobbies & crafts options
Field Notes
Hobbies & CraftsPocket-sized memo books sold in 3-packs, plus quarterly limited editions by subscription.
Connecting Threads
Hobbies & CraftsOnline quilting shop with its own fabric lines, thread, kits, patterns and supplies.
Warlord Games
Hobbies & CraftsTabletop wargames and 28mm miniatures, from Bolt Action WWII to Black Powder and sci-fi lines.
Piecework Puzzles
Hobbies & CraftsDesign-led jigsaw puzzles in 300 to 1000 pieces, plus puzzle accessories and gifts.
Redcat Racing
Hobbies & CraftsReady-to-run RC crawlers, lowriders, trucks and buggies from 1/32 to 1/6 scale, with a 1-year warranty.
Kiwi Crate (KiwiCo)
Hobbies & CraftsMonthly hands-on science, art and engineering project kits for kids, from babies to teens and adults.
Airfix
Hobbies & CraftsClassic British plastic model kits of aircraft, tanks, ships and more, plus starter sets and paints.
Tennis Express
Hobbies & CraftsHouston-based tennis specialty shop selling racquets, shoes, apparel and stringing, with a pickleball sister store.
Lovepop
Hobbies & CraftsPop-up greeting cards and paper gifts, with personal message inserts and same-day delivery in some areas.
ReadyWise
Hobbies & CraftsLong-shelf-life emergency food kits, bulk meal pouches and survival backpacks.
Ultra PRO
Hobbies & CraftsCard sleeves, toploaders, binders, deck boxes and playmats for collectors and tabletop gamers.
CRBN Pickleball
Hobbies & CraftsCarbon-fiber pickleball paddles in several shapes, with a 30-day trial and free shipping and returns.
Nikon (binoculars)
Hobbies & CraftsNikon's range of binoculars, from compact ACTION and PROSTAFF models to MONARCH birding optics.
Engage Pickleball
Hobbies & CraftsPickleball paddle maker with a limited lifetime warranty and a 30-day test drive.
Derwent
Hobbies & CraftsBritish art pencil brand known for Inktense, watercolour and coloured pencils, sold direct online.
Jackson's Art Supplies
Hobbies & CraftsUK-based online art shop with paints, brushes and papers from big brands plus its own Jackson's range.
Clever Fox
Hobbies & CraftsPrinted planners and journals for goals, budgets, fitness and more, with free US, Canada and UK shipping.
PlayBetter
Hobbies & CraftsUS golf tech store for launch monitors, home simulators, rangefinders and GPS watches, with free 2-day shipping.
Hape
Hobbies & CraftsWooden and eco-minded toys for babies and kids, from play kitchens and dollhouses to puzzles and marble runs.
UPrinting
Hobbies & CraftsOnline print shop for business cards, stickers, banners, packaging and apparel with a free file check.
Formlabs
Hobbies & CraftsProfessional resin (SLA) and powder (SLS) 3D printers, with in-house materials and PreForm software.
Wayland Games
Hobbies & CraftsUK hobby store for Warhammer, board games, card games and LEGO, often below RRP with free UK delivery over £20.
The Woobles
Hobbies & CraftsBeginner-friendly crochet kits for cute animals and characters, with step-by-step online tutorials.
Selkirk Sport
Hobbies & CraftsPickleball paddles, shoes, apparel and gear, with lines from entry-level SLK to premium Boomstik.
Rapsodo
Hobbies & CraftsPortable golf launch monitors and baseball tracking devices, with optional Premium memberships.
Ghost Golf
Hobbies & CraftsGolf stand bags, cart bags and staff bags with bold designs.
Appointed
Hobbies & CraftsAmerican-made planners, notebooks, calendars and desk stationery with a clean, minimal design.
Liquitex
Hobbies & CraftsAcrylic paint maker since 1955, with professional and Basics paints, inks, markers, sprays and mediums.
True Leaf Market
Hobbies & CraftsNon-GMO garden, microgreens and sprouting seeds plus growing kits, shipped from Salt Lake City.
Burpee
Hobbies & CraftsLong-running US seed company selling non-GMO vegetable and flower seeds, live plants and garden supplies.
Blick Art Materials
Hobbies & CraftsLarge US art supply store with 110,000+ products, free shipping from $89 and a one-year return guarantee.
Ravensburger
Hobbies & CraftsGerman maker of jigsaw puzzles, family games and creative toys, sold through its own US online shop.
Hobbii
Hobbies & CraftsDanish online yarn shop with low-priced own-brand yarns, 16,500+ patterns and free shipping from $49.99.
Botanical Interests
Hobbies & CraftsColorado seed company selling untreated, non-GMO vegetable, flower and herb seeds with detailed growing guides.
Ohuhu
Hobbies & CraftsArt marker brand selling large alcohol, acrylic and water-based marker sets at moderate prices.
Epic Gardening
Hobbies & CraftsGardening store and how-to brand selling seeds, metal raised beds and seed-starting gear.
Tower Hobbies
Hobbies & CraftsLong-running online hobby store for RC cars, planes, boats, model trains and model kits.
Element Games
Hobbies & CraftsUK wargaming shop selling Warhammer, paints, board games and card games at discounted prices.
Fast Growing Trees (Trees.com)
Hobbies & CraftsOnline plant nursery shipping trees, shrubs and plants across the US, with a 1-year plant guarantee.
Snapmaker
Hobbies & CraftsDesktop 3D printers, including a four-toolhead multi-color printer and a 3-in-1 printer with laser and CNC.
White Flower Farm
Hobbies & CraftsFamily-owned Connecticut mail-order nursery selling bulbs, perennials, shrubs, amaryllis and garden gifts.
Knit Picks
Hobbies & CraftsOnline yarn store with low-priced house-brand yarns, needles, kits and knitting patterns.
theory11
Hobbies & CraftsPremium playing cards, jigsaw puzzles and magic tricks, including licensed decks for films and shows.
Miniature Market
Hobbies & CraftsUS online shop for board games, miniatures, trading cards and RPGs, with flat-rate and free shipping tiers.
Robotime
Hobbies & CraftsDIY 3D wooden puzzles, mechanical models and miniature house kits under the ROKR and Rolife brands.
Lion Brand Yarn
Hobbies & CraftsFamily-owned US yarn brand selling yarn, kits, patterns and tools for knitting and crochet.
Compare all hobbies & crafts side by side →
This summary is based on Star City Games's official website, pricing page and public documentation as of November 15, 2026. Prices and features change, so confirm the details on the official site. Some links on this site may be affiliate links. See our affiliate disclosure.