Home / Outdoor & Sports Gear / Mystery Tackle Box
Outdoor & Sports Gear

Mystery Tackle Box review: what it is, pricing and who it's for

Monthly fishing tackle subscription with baits picked for your target species, from $19.99 a month.

Last checked November 16, 2026

In short: Monthly fishing tackle subscription with baits picked for your target species, from $19.99 a month. Starting price: Regular plan from $19.99/month. Best for: Anglers who want to try new lures each month.

What is Mystery Tackle Box?

Mystery Tackle Box is a monthly subscription that sends a box of fishing baits and tackle chosen by its team. You pick a plan and the species you fish for, and each month's box contains items from tackle brands matched to that species.

There are three monthly plans with more items in higher tiers, plus prepaid gift plans that do not renew. Boxes also include decals and access to how-to videos, and the site sells tackle kits, bundles and apparel separately.

Key features

  • Three tiers: Regular (4-6 baits), Pro (6-8) and Elite (8-10).
  • Choose your target species (5 on Regular, 6 on Pro, 3 on Elite).
  • Tackle chosen monthly from fishing brands.
  • Prepaid gift plans that do not auto-renew.
  • Multi-month plans with occasional bonus tackle kits.
  • Custom decals, how-to videos and monthly competitions.
  • Tackle kits, bundles, backpacks and apparel sold separately.

Plans and pricing

PlanPrice / limitIncludes
RegularFrom $19.99/month4-6 baits, choose from 5 species
ProFrom $31.99/month6-8 baits, choose from 6 species
EliteFrom $44.99/month8-10 baits, choose from 3 species
Gift plansFrom $82Paid upfront, no renewal

Prices in US dollars as listed on 16 Nov 2026; shipping and cancellation terms are in the help centre and were not confirmed.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Low entry price for a monthly box.
  • Baits matched to the species you target.
  • Gift plans that end on their own, with no renewal.
  • Good way to discover new lures and brands.

Cons

  • You do not choose the exact items, so some baits may not suit your waters.
  • Elite plan offers fewer species choices.
  • Monthly plans renew automatically until cancelled.
  • Shipping and cancellation terms are not shown on the main plan pages.

Who it's for

Fits anglers who enjoy surprises and want to try new tackle regularly, and makes an easy gift. Anglers who already know exactly what lures they want will get better value buying them directly.

Frequently asked questions

What is Mystery Tackle Box?

Mystery Tackle Box is a monthly subscription that sends a box of fishing baits and tackle chosen by its team. You pick a plan and the species you fish for, and each month's box contains items from tackle brands matched to that species.

How much does Mystery Tackle Box cost?

Mystery Tackle Box starts at Regular plan from $19.99/month. Prices in US dollars as listed on 16 Nov 2026; shipping and cancellation terms are in the help centre and were not confirmed.

Who is Mystery Tackle Box best for?

Fits anglers who enjoy surprises and want to try new tackle regularly, and makes an easy gift. Anglers who already know exactly what lures they want will get better value buying them directly.

What are the downsides of Mystery Tackle Box?

Main drawbacks: You do not choose the exact items, so some baits may not suit your waters. Elite plan offers fewer species choices. Monthly plans renew automatically until cancelled. Shipping and cancellation terms are not shown on the main plan pages.

What are some alternatives to Mystery Tackle Box?

Other outdoor & sports gear options we cover include Kettlebell Kings, Mountain Hardwear, Saris, RVshare and Deuter.

Other outdoor & sports gear options

K

Kettlebell Kings

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Kettlebell specialist selling competition, powder-coat and adjustable bells plus racks and training kits.

M

Mountain Hardwear

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Outdoor clothing and gear brand known for down jackets, shells, tents and sleeping bags.

S

Saris

Outdoor & Sports Gear

US maker of car bike racks, indoor bike trainers and home bike storage, with free US shipping over $150.

R

RVshare

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Peer-to-peer RV rental marketplace with motorhomes and trailers from private owners in all 50 US states.

D

Deuter

Outdoor & Sports Gear

German backpack maker for hiking, backpacking, ski touring and child carriers, with free pack repairs.

R

Retrospec

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Affordable bikes, e-bikes, paddle boards, skateboards and outdoor gear sold direct, with free US shipping over $35.

C

Christy Sports

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Ski and snowboard retailer with 50+ stores in the Rockies, offering gear, daily and season rentals.

S

Smith Optics

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Snow goggles, sunglasses and helmets with ChromaPop contrast lenses for skiing, biking and fishing.

E

Engel Coolers

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Hard, soft and drybox coolers plus portable fridge-freezers from a cooling brand dating back to 1962.

O

Outdoor Gear Exchange

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Vermont outdoor shop selling new, used and outlet gear for camping, climbing, skiing and biking.

E

Eco-Worthy

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Solar panels, LiFePO4 batteries, inverters and off-grid kits for RVs, cabins and home backup.

I

ICECO

Outdoor & Sports Gear

12V portable fridge-freezers for camping, overlanding and vanlife, in single and dual zone sizes.

H

Harvest Hosts

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Yearly RV membership for free overnight stays at wineries, farms, breweries and other small businesses.

L

LiTime

Outdoor & Sports Gear

LiFePO4 lithium batteries, chargers, inverters and solar controllers for RVs, boats and off-grid setups.

C

Chaco

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Outdoor strap sandals plus clogs and boots, with a repair service to extend their life.

T

Tifosi Optics

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Affordable sport sunglasses and prescription frames for cycling, running, golf and pickleball.

O

Outdoor Vitals

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Ultralight backpacking gear: down quilts, sleeping bags, packs, tents and technical apparel.

i

iKamper

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Hardshell and softshell rooftop tents, plus annexes, awnings and sleep gear for overlanding.

G

Garmin inReach

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Satellite messengers for texting, location sharing and SOS where there is no cell signal.

S

Snow Peak

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Japanese camping brand making premium tents, titanium mugs, cookware and fire gear guaranteed for life.

L

LifeStraw

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Water filters for hiking, travel and home, from personal straws to bottles, pitchers and dispensers.

M

Mystery Ranch

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Heavy-duty backpacks for hunting, military, wildland fire and everyday carry, backed by a lifetime warranty.

T

Topo Designs

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Colorful packs, travel bags and outdoor-inspired clothing, with a lifetime warranty on bags.

E

EXPED

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Swiss outdoor brand making sleeping mats, sleeping bags, tents and packs, with a 5-year warranty.

G

Goal Zero

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Portable power stations, solar panels and lights for camping, vans and home backup.

C

CamelBak

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Maker of hydration packs, water bottles and travel mugs, backed by a lifetime guarantee on defects.

L

La Sportiva

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Italian mountain brand making climbing shoes, trail runners, hiking boots, ski gear and technical apparel.

R

ROUVY

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Indoor cycling app that lets you ride real-world routes, workouts and races on your home trainer.

P

PEARL iZUMi

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Cycling apparel brand with jerseys, bib shorts, jackets, gloves and shoes for road, gravel and mountain riders.

R

Rad Power Bikes

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Direct-to-consumer electric bikes, focused on cargo and utility models with 750W motors.

L

LOWA Boots

Outdoor & Sports Gear

German-founded maker of hiking, mountaineering, hunting and duty boots, with a 60-day fit return window.

L

Lems Shoes

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Zero-drop, wide-toe barefoot-style shoes and boots for running, hiking and everyday wear.

G

GRAYL

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Press-style water purifier bottles that remove viruses, bacteria and protozoa for travel and hiking.

B

Big Agnes

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Colorado-based maker of lightweight tents, sleeping bags and sleeping pads for backpacking and camping.

S

Sea to Summit

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Australian outdoor brand known for dry bags, sleeping pads and compact camp kitchen gear.

S

SCARPA

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Italian maker of ski boots, climbing shoes, hiking and mountaineering footwear for serious outdoor use.

S

Stanley 1913

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Insulated tumblers, bottles, lunch boxes and camp gear, with lifetime cover on stainless-steel products.

P

Priority Bicycles

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Low-maintenance belt-drive, gearbox and electric bikes sold direct online in the US.

D

DAHON

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Long-running folding bike maker with compact city folders, e-bikes and road and gravel models.

R

Ridge Merino

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Merino wool base layers, underwear, tees and fleece for outdoor sports, with 90-day free US returns.

P

Pickleball Central

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Pickleball store with paddles, balls, nets, shoes and a free 30-day paddle test drive.

O

Outdoorsy

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Peer-to-peer RV and camper van rental marketplace with protection packages and 24/7 roadside help.

F

Farm to Feet

Outdoor & Sports Gear

US-made merino wool socks for hiking, everyday wear, snow sports, hunting and work, backed by a satisfaction guarantee.

C

Cruise America

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Class C motorhome rentals from 100+ rental centers in the US and Canada, with one-way trips available.

S

Stix Golf

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Direct-to-consumer golf club sets sold online, with complete 7 to 14-club sets from $699.

A

Augason Farms

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Long-shelf-life emergency food kits, pails and cans, many rated for up to 25 years of storage.

S

Swarovski Optik

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Austrian premium optics: binoculars, spotting scopes and riflescopes for birding and hunting.

B

Bollé

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Eyewear brand for sport sunglasses, ski goggles and helmets, known for photochromic and contrast lenses.

T

The Dyrt

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Camping app for finding campgrounds and free campsites, with offline maps and an RV trip planner in PRO.

U

Uneekor

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Camera-based golf launch monitors for home simulators and practice, in overhead and portable ground models.

A

AFTCO

Outdoor & Sports Gear

California fishing brand since 1958 making fishing apparel and saltwater tackle, with free shipping over $99.

G

Garage Grown Gear

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Online shop for ultralight backpacking gear from 200+ small and cottage brands, free US shipping over $50.

H

HUK Gear

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Performance fishing apparel with UPF sun protection, quick-dry fabrics and fleece for salt, fresh and fly anglers.

M

Mountain House

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Freeze-dried meals for backpacking and emergency storage, ready with boiling water and backed by a 30-year taste guarantee.

S

STITCH Golf

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Lightweight golf bags, travel bags and golf apparel, with customisable Make It Yours bag options.

P

Paddletek

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Pickleball paddle maker with Bantam, Tempest and Phoenix lines, plus padel rackets and apparel.

H

Hestra Gloves

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Glove maker since 1936 with ski, outdoor, leather and dress gloves for men, women and kids.

G

Gaia GPS

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Offline maps and route planning app for hiking, backcountry skiing and overlanding.

R

Royal Robbins

Outdoor & Sports Gear

Outdoor and travel clothing brand founded by climbers in Yosemite in 1968.

B

BougeRV

Outdoor & Sports Gear

12V portable fridges, flexible solar panels and camping gear for RVs, vans and car camping.

Compare all outdoor & sports gear side by side →

This summary is based on Mystery Tackle Box's official website, pricing page and public documentation as of November 16, 2026. Prices and features change, so confirm the details on the official site. Some links on this site may be affiliate links. See our affiliate disclosure.